Docs seek stop to expensive, experimental stem cell therapy

A+
A
A-

MANILA, Philippines—Saying that doctors were exacting “exorbitant fees” for what is still experimental medicine, the Philippine College of Physicians (PCP) launched Tuesday an online petition urging the Department of Health (DOH) to put a stop to “experimental” stem cell therapies in the country.

“Human stem cell therapy for unproven indications is proliferating in the Philippines and posing serious safety issues to unknowing Filipinos… The Philippine College of Physicians is alarmed by the false claims, misinformation and exorbitant fees for such stem cell treatments,” read the petition on www.change.org.

The PCP urged the DOH to issue a cease and desist order to all doctors performing such therapies as the Philippine Health Insurance Corp. (PhilHealth) clarified that stem cell therapy was not covered by the government’s universal healthcare program.

Cease and desist

“We, the undersigned, call on the (DOH) to issue a cease and desist order to all doctors, clinics and hospitals that [offer] human stem cell therapy for unproven indications until scientific evidence to support claims of efficacy and safety are approved by the Food and Drug Administration,” it said.

The PCP, the umbrella organization of Internal Medicine specialists in the country, said that transplanting “human blood-forming stem cells” to treat cancerous and noncancerous diseases of the blood was the most widely accepted clinical application of stem cell therapy.

“The effectiveness and safety of human stem cell therapy has yet to be proven for heart, neurologic, skin, rheumatologic and gastrointestinal diseases, diabetes, hypertension, autism, cancer, aging and aesthetics, HIV/AIDS and other conditions,” the group said.

Lack of evidence

“Despite the lack of solid scientific evidence to support the [application] of human stem cell therapy for these conditions, reports of its use precisely for these conditions being received and exorbitant fees being paid by prominent personalities abound in media,” the PCP said.

It said that this could mislead the public into accepting stem cell therapy which “is at best experimental at this time.”

“Good ethical practice dictates that when treatment is experimental, the patient should not pay for it but instead should be compensated for altruism in participating in a clinical trial for a treatment that has not yet been proven completely effective or safe,” the PCP said.

“The use of human stem cells for unproven indications should be confined to clinical studies that have been screened and approved by a duly constituted technical review board and ethics committee,” it further said.

The group said that human stem cell therapies should be duly registered with the FDA and performed only in DOH-accredited centers.

PhilHealth says no

PhilHealth, meanwhile, said it was not paying for stem cell therapy but if it were later certified as “a standard care,” it would have to undergo evaluation first.

Under Republic Act No. 10606, the law creating the National Health Insurance Program of 2013, as amended, “the Corporation [PhilHealth] shall not cover expenses for health services considered … as cost ineffective through health technology assessment … in keeping with its protection objectives and financial sustainability.”

“All new technologies, including stem cell therapy, shall undergo the process of assessment if they can be developed into a benefit package or be excluded from the same,” PhilHealth said.

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • kismaytami

    Kapag gumaling na kasi ang isang pasyente sa tamang stem cell therapy, hindi na niya kailangang kumonsulta sa duktor, kaya walang kita si doc na mahilig magpabalik-balik sa kanyang mga pasyente.

    • TEAM PNOY

      You do not know what you are talking. You think you know better than the doctors? Go ahead and have your bogus stem cell therapy. In the meantime, we will stay away from it.

      • kismaytami

        What do you think about the doctors you are visiting? Aren’t they not making a guinea pig out of you while asking exorbitant ‘consultation’ fees? Why do you think they are telling you to come back often?. And by the way, you misunderstood me, I’m not talking about your so called ‘bogus’ stem cell therapies.

      • TEAM PNOY

        Well, if you encounter an unethical doctor who is making you his guinea pig and asking exorbitant consultation fees, stay away from that doctor/s! Do not go back even if he is telling you to go back. You have a freewill, use it prudently. Cheers.

    • rem1911

      The problem is that stem cell therapy is still experimental. Usually for other medicines/procedures, during it’s experimental stage, test subjects aka patients or participants in the experiment are given the medicine for FREE . They need to have these experimental stage to be approved by the BFAD and DOH. What is surprising is that doctors and hospital charged exorbitant fees, for a procedure that should be free because its just experimental.

    • epokine

      kaya di umunlad bayan natin dahil sa mga kagaya mong mag-isip. Get your facts para maiwasan ang mga stupid comments.

  • TEAM PNOY

    I have been observing the philippine college of physicians as a layman, I think this organization is ethical and morally upright. Stem cell therapy is really in an experimental stage. Please do not allow yourself to be a human guinea pig and be extorted with exorbitant medical fees!

  • txtman

    __________ MUKHANG PERA _______
    .
    DAMI DYAN GANYAN
    ____ HINDI BA DRA. SI GARIN?
    ____ HINDI BA DRA. SI CABRAL?
    PERA-PERA LANG DYAN
    .
    TAPOS CONDOMS DAW SAGOT
    SA MATERNAL DEATHS?????
    _____ MGA BOBA
    _____ ONLY IN THE PHILIPPINES
    PWEEEEEEE
    PITIFUL

  • disqus_1RoYcJ1D6S

    Ang taong may malubhang karamdaman ay gagawin ang lahat para siya ay gumaling, kahit pa gawin siyang guinea pig. What more if he or she has the money to spend?

    • epokine

      yeah, we understand your sentiments but the MAIN ISSUE is on ETHICS. The only legal and accepted clinical application of stem cell therapy is the BONE MARROW TRANSPLANT indicated for certain blood problems performed by a HEMATOLOGIST. Its effectiveness and safety has yet to be proven for other conditions, hence experimental pa lang. Since experimental pa lang, it is UNETHICAL that doctors received payment for exorbitant fees, instead the patient should receive it for FREE and that should be screened and duly approved by TRB and ethics committee.

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94