Mariah starts strong as she shows off her “M” necklace inspired by the jewelry worn by leading characters Regina George and Cady Heron.
The quiz has three parts. Mariah aces the first “Yes or No” round. Mariah peppers in specific details about the film connected to the items, showing off how much of a fan she is.
The second round consists of general trivia. During the question about the winter talent show scene, Mariah confronted Tina about the movie’s song choice. “I’m a little bit disappointed they’re not dancing to my song. But ‘Jingle Bell Rock’ is a little bit older than ‘All I Want for Christmas Is You’ so okay.”
Tina quickly redeemed herself by saying she’ll make a Mean Girls reboot so that Mariah can do a song for it. She also offered Mariah a part in the movie. Mariah replies, “I definitely want to be in it as well, I don’t know as who. But maybe I could be friends with Amy Poehler as her other friend who wears sweatsuits.” Can someone please take this pitch seriously?
In the last round, Tina throws memorable Mean Girls quotes, and Mariah has to identify who said it. Tina also asks Mariah personal questions so the hitmaker could share tidbits about her real-life and plug her memoir.
“I was pretty mean because I was just trying to fit in, and that was the only way I could fit in. Because I only had three shirts in rotation. My father did not invent Toaster Strudel at all,” Mariah says as explains why she understood Cady’s motivations.